Saturday, November 21, 2026

The Arithmetic is Easy, the Solution is Almost Impossible

Developed countries in Europe are seeing massive protests and the USA experienced a blue tsunami.  Affordability, inequality and crumbling infrastructure are universal plagues across the world.  The arithmetic behind these crises has many variables but is easy to understand in broad terms and points to a very challenging future.

The problem areas are ironically good news/bad news combinations.  The good news is that people are living longer - the bad news is that social security has to foot the bill for multiple decades of retirement, often as long as the 30-40 years that people worked.  

The good news is that medical science is increasingly capable of curing diseases and increasing longevity.  The bad news is that healthcare costs increase almost exponentially and the final years of living are phenomenally expensive.

The good news is that birth control and changes in social norms have given women flexibility in when, if and how many children they will bear.  The bad news is that the decline in birthrates are at least temporarily reducing the revenue required to support older, retired generations.

The good news is that computer, Internet and AI technology have vastly expanded access to knowledge and entertainment options, made us somewhat more productive, and generated massive wealth.  The bad news is that much or perhaps most of this wealth has gone to a small percentage of people, further exacerbating the income and wealth inequality that appeared to be abating in the mid-twentieth century.

The good news is that international trade and globalization have increased the availability of goods and services around the world and raised hundreds of millions of its citizens from poverty to middle class.  The bad news is that job loss/outsourcing, immigration and wage stagnation have created huge dissatisfaction and resentment in the working class.

Can the world ‘grow’ itself out of this downward spiral or will we have to make some hard choices about redistributing the world’s riches?  Increasing taxes on the wealthy is almost always impossible, quite simply because the wealthy have so much political power (and now control all of social media as well!)  The only times significant changes in wealth tax and redistribution have occurred in the past were after cataclysmic events like depressions or wars.  The recent demonstrations and riots may indicate that such events will very possibly occur again in the near future.  But that is hardly an outcome that we can feel good about 

The tech billionaire class and their minions don’t like messy social problems, and they are indignant at efforts to tax or appropriate their fortunes for the greater good.  Their firm belief is that AI, and its progeny such as AGI, will ultimately fix all problems. How this will transpire is still somewhat hazy.  If AI and robots with AI do pretty much everything for humankind, then I guess we don’t have to worry.  But you can bet the transition won’t be pretty.  In the meantime, investment capital and resources that could have been used to ameliorate the more mundane but rapidly escalating problems cited above are being totally dedicated to the AI arms race.

The arithmetic of our discontent is not hard to comprehend: too many aging, retired people; increasingly capable, but expensive healthcare, much of which is used in keeping those retired people alive; long neglected infrastructure; costs of housing, grocery, transportation, education and childcare rising faster than wages.  

Putting all our bets on AI to rescue us seems a bit irresponsible to me, but when you have created a winner-takes-all world and can frame everything in terms of ‘beating the Chinese’, then what can you expect?

Monday, November 16, 2026

It is Necessary, not Naive, to Focus on Diplomacy with China

The recent honeypot scandal with Nvidia’s Jensen Huang has led to a veritable hysteria over China’s efforts to obtain the best technology and products.  Both republicans and democrats have vied to express China’s rise and so-called underhanded tactics in the most apocalyptic terms possible.

First of all, let’s not kid ourselves and try to appear as if we have some moral high ground.  Our CIA would not hesitate in the slightest to use a honeypot scheme to gain important intelligence or critical technology.  It’s a lot less pernicious than the assassinations of leaders and scientists that we and Israel have executed so frequently over the years.

China is highly motivated to continue to expand its economy in any way possible.  It has a lot of challenges and the growing expectations of its billion plus citizens put it in a somewhat precarious position.  Additionally, it has a long history of being exploited by the west and probably feels completely justified in staking its claim to economic domination.  Turnabout is fair play, right?

But China is no longer just a huge factory for cheap Walmart goods.  Chinese scientists and engineers are incredibly capable, and Chinese industry is no longer dependent on ‘stealing’ western trade secrets or copying technology.  Their recent strides in AI, solar and wind energy, and automotive are evidence of innovation and entrepreneurship that must be respected and acknowledged.

China may not currently be capable of building the most advanced data center microchips, but denying them access to this technology will only ensure that they focus their best minds and technology on leapfrogging Nvidia, as they have done with solar and automotive technologies. 

If we continue to portray China as untrustworthy, duplicitous and some sort of evil empire, we will increase their distrust and somewhat understandable paranoia.  We will compel them to act unilaterally and skirt any economic or political barriers that stand in their way.  

The time of Trumpian unilateralism and adversarial practices must come to an end.  The world faces too many problems jointly to have individual superpowers act only on their own behalf.  The current path of demonizing China will surely lead to an arms race on many different fronts - AI, rare earth minerals, advanced microchips, alternative energy, biotechnology and weaponry to name a few. Moreover, it will only encourage them to act even more aggressively in dominating world markets.  The end result will be a bankrupt world with ever more desperate nations and peoples attempting to survive rather than prosper.

It is no easy task, but the whole world would benefit from a strong, cooperative friendship between China and the USA.  It is time to see China as an equal and reliable partner in improving the lives of all the world’s citizens and solving the myriad problems that we all face.  

As in all partnerships, trust must be built and nurtured.  Sincere efforts must be made to compromise on thorny issues.  But if the USA were to stop attempting to thwart the Chinese juggernaut and work in harmony with it, recognizing it as a valid peer and even successor, then the world will have a much better chance of making it to the 22nd century.


Friday, November 6, 2026

Oh Schadenfreude, how sweet thou art!

Texas goes blue and cybertruck production is scheduled to ‘wind down’!  For the millions of Americans who have watched in disgust as Elon Musk has attempted to manipulate our democracy with his wealth and launch his Mad Max, neo-nazi fever dream truck, these two pieces of news could not be more welcome.

The golden boy has now tasted failure in a big way, and sympathy is in short supply.  The former climate hero innovator took a big right turn sometime around 2020, and the legions that used to swoon over his genius and vision now find his arrogance detestable and his megalomania frightening.

Once upon a time, Elon seemed like a smart guy with an admirable passion for fighting climate change with electric vehicles.  A little quirky perhaps, but embodying a new spirit of innovation in technology that could make a positive impact.


Ten years later, after massive meddling in the 2024 election on Trump’s behalf, a cruel, chaotic and disastrous DOGE-gutting of federal agencies, a shocking, on-stage Heil Hitler moment of frenzied egotism and the repurposing of Twitter/X into a right wing echo chamber, Musk has lost his allure and his adoring followers.  Only the MAGA faithful and a subset of lost boy tech wannabes are still in his thrall.  


The cybertruck is an apt symbol of Musk’s persona - brutish, styleless and sinister.  It appeals to the bully, the macho man, the angry and frustrated alpha male.  Its demise is a welcome sign that we are not yet degenerating into some sort of dystopian, Zombie future.


The millions he used to shove negative ads and conspiracy theories down the throats of Texans not only failed to turn the Democratic tide, but they probably had just the opposite effect.  Musk may be more pariah than savior at this point, and what rational person does not weep tears of joy at this turn of events?


The German word Schadenfreude rolls deliciously off my tongue as I contemplate the twin portents of Musk’s decline.  I know it is not nice to revel in another’s failure, but it sure feels good!


Saturday, October 24, 2026

Subscription Hell

I just received a notice that my 2021 version of MS Office is no longer supported and that I must either purchase Office 2024 or subscribe to Microsoft 365.

I have used the same features on Word and Excel since I first purchased them 25 years ago.  The only service Microsoft is providing me now is security updates. And I am pretty sure that is the case for most users. To pay hundreds of dollars a year for these updates is ludicrous.  


I will now switch to Google Docs and Sheets.  They are still free, but who knows for how long?  The addition of Gemini and other AI gimmicks is likely to create an unavoidable paywall in the future.  Or they will somehow shove ads into the experience.


This is the inevitable ‘enshittification’ (Cory Doctorow’s theory) of applications, social media and online services or platforms.  Either you end up enduring unending advertisements or pay fees for applications that you have previously purchased and still use in the exact same way.  And those fees continuously increase.


Recurring charges and endless ads are the bane of modern existence.  To add insult to injury, this enshittification is the revenue engine that gives us arrogant billionaires like Zuckerberg, Bezos, Ellison, Thiel, Altman, Brin, Andreessen and many others, who posture as all-knowing prophets and meddle disproportionately in politics.


Once upon a time there was a movement that advocated having critical software be open source and available for free use by everyone.  I know it is naive to wish for such a world and that the digital revolution has brought many amazing things into our lives, but this steady drumbeat of ads and subscriptions is a nightmare.  Where will it all lead?  Is there no way out?


Thursday, September 24, 2026

The Plutocrat Feedback Loop

It feels like billionaires become more arrogant, more entitled, wealthier and more politically influential by the minute.  Something is horribly out of balance.  But it isn’t hard to see why.  It is quite simply the plutocrat feedback loop.

A feedback loop is a system where there are circular, reinforcing (or in the case of negative feedback, braking) effects.  Feedback loops are common in almost any system, whether mechanical, electrical, economic or societal.

When a business is successful its founders benefit from its success through profits but even more so from their ownership.  Industries in the past often required years or even decades of growth and capital expenditures to provide their owners with massive wealth.  Factories took time to build and markets were limited by transportation costs and the reach of marketing efforts. 

The modern world of finance and technology often provide a small group of entrepreneurs and investors with almost unimaginable wealth in just a few years.  The network effect quickly establishes a quasi-monopoly to the first few entrants to a modern market because who wants to try a different social media platform when all your friends and family and business associates are on the first one?  Who wants to use a new office app if everyone you interact with uses MS Office?  Who wants to use a new money transfer app if everyone you know uses Venmo?

When owners and investors quickly get fabulously wealthy, they are able to invest in start-ups either individually or through venture capital companies.  This creates a community of wealth and networking that attracts new opportunities and generates new success stories producing more wealth.  

This is a feedback mechanism – wealth producing more wealth.  It is a key part of capitalism, but the modern world has seen this feedback loop become incredibly fast because finance and tech companies require little buildout and relatively few human resources as well.  The time from concept to billion-dollar acquisition or IPO has shrunk dramatically.

A second feedback loop for plutocrats is the ‘I am a master of the universe’ effect.  It is only natural for someone to gain confidence after building a successful company.  But the hyper-celebrity nature of today’s entrepreneurs can easily exaggerate that sense of accomplishment and produce a growing sense of superiority.  Wealth also creates a legion of sycophants who are only too eager to confirm that superiority to be able to share a bit in the reflected glory and the crumbs that are leftover from the plutocrat banquet.

As new investments produce more wealth and one’s social circle becomes an echo chamber of other big ego plutocrats, a God complex is easily developed:  I am uniquely gifted!  I need to share my wisdom and genius with the world!  My ideas and philosophy are far superior to those of the morons and peons who drag this world down!

The most dangerous feedback loop is the political one.  Great wealth plays heavily into American politics.  It buys elections, it buys influence, it buys policy, it buys positions.  And all of that influence serves to create political, economic and social policy that reinforces the wealth, the industries, and the stature of the plutocrats.  A wealth tax?  No way!  Higher income taxes?  Not in my lifetime!  Some regulation of the crypto scam?  Are you kidding?  A more measured pace for AI and data centers?  Of course not – we’ll lose to the Chinese!  A serious analysis of big tech monopolies?  That’s socialism!  A closer look at the harm inflicted by social media algorithms?  That’s limiting free speech!

These feedback loops are powerful and they are growing and accelerating.  The world we inhabit now, with grotesquely unfair distributions of wealth and income, with climate change already inflicting great damage, with autocrats multiplying and unilateralism becoming the norm, is to a great extent a product of these feedback loops.  While we still have democracies (however weak they have become) in place we must do something to diminish their growth and impact.  

It is abundantly clear that plutocrats are the wrong people to trust with the future of the earth and human civilization.  But we must act now or they will prevail.


Sunday, September 13, 2026

Some Perspective on American High-tech Exceptionalism

I love my country.  It is my home and where I have spent almost all of my life.  I love the incredibly diverse landscape, I love the people (or at least most of them . . .), I love the culture, I love the energy and the friendliness that generally prevails across our land.  

But I don’t love my country because it is better than other countries.  I don’t subscribe to that notion.  America, like every other nation on earth, has its beauty, its wonder and its admirable traits.  But also like every other nation, it has some very unfortunate habits and faults.

Our over-the-top patriotism and boastful claim to a unique ‘exceptionalism’ is one of these.  In the disastrous age of Trump, this unchecked boosterism has attained epic heights and any criticism or more nuanced appraisal of our history and our accomplishments is seen as anti-American, ‘woke’ and treasonous.

At the risk of being similarly branded, I want to take a more nuanced look at our domination of the age of computer and information technology.  There is no doubt that US companies dominate the high-tech world.  But is this domination purely American?  And is it tied to our uniquely exceptional country and its uniquely exceptional people?

There was this little thing called World War II that occurred just before the middle of the twentieth century.  And guess what?  The USA was the only industrial nation that came out of the war without catastrophic damage. In fact, having expanded dramatically as the ‘arsenal of democracy’, it was actually stronger than when the war started.

The invention and rapid development of the transistor and silicon technology launched the computer age.  It is no surprise that a country that had emerged stronger from both world wars would be in a position to make these innovations.  The creation of technology hubs in Massachusetts and California benefited from the readily available investment capital of the wealthiest nation in the world and research from the best endowed universities.

There is a ‘network effect’ when something achieves a certain level of achievement and begins to attract similar things.  History is replete with examples – Athens during the Golden Age of Greece, Florence  during the Renaissance, Manchester and Liverpool during the early industrial revolution, and Germany’s universities during the rise of scientific discovery there in the late 1800’s.  The rise of Silicon Valley, Route 128 in Boston and other tech hubs was the natural outcome of a confluence of factors that created this network effect.

As the computer hardware revolution spawned the software and information age, which required less capital expense and investment, the key innovations became a bit more international.  Software languages were invented by engineers from many different countries – Peter Naur (Danish) and Niklaus Wirth (Swiss) invented many of the early languages (ALGOL, PL360, Pascal, Modula) that paved the way beyond the limitations of FORTRAN and COBOL.  Other international players introduced concepts of object-oriented programming.

Soon thereafter, computer software and network hardware enabled the invention of the Internet. The underlying networking protocols (TCP/IP) were developed at DARPA, a US defense department organization, by Americans Bob Kahn and Vinton Cerf.  But the higher-level protocols and concepts that enabled the World Wide Web (HTTP and the browser) were created by British engineer Tim Berners-Lee at CERN, the European Organization for Nuclear Research.  

The years following the advent of the Internet saw furious advances in software and networking.  Many different languages were invented.  European software developers contributed heavily to these advances.  C++, Python and PHP were all invented by Europeans, and Java by a Canadian.  The most prevalent operating system in the world, Linux, was invented by a Finnish computer scientist, Linus Torvalds.

As we hurtle into the AI era (perhaps our last era?), it is interesting to note that many of the key breakthrough concepts and techniques that created the world of neural networks, chatbots, and LLMs were developed at the University of Toronto by a group of computer scientists including Geoffrey Hinton, Yann LeCun,  Alex Krizhevsky and Ilya Sutskever.  Hinton formed a company, DNNResearch, in Toronto, which was acquired by Google to supercharge its AI subsidiary, Google Brain.

Intelligence and creativity are human attributes that defy national boundaries.  Even entrepreneurship is a universal and somewhat primal urge.  But investment capital, networking opportunities, talent pools and other seductive aspects of technology hubs have a strong magnetic pull and attract would-be innovators from across the world.

Yes, America is the envy of the world for its prowess in technology.  But how it got there and how it sustains that prestige is not a simple question of American exceptionalism.  It is a combination of timing, available investment capital, the network effect and momentum. America is a wonderful place, but the wide world is just as wonderful and as the saying goes, we stand on the shoulders of those creative and energetic men and women from across the world who propel us forward.


Saturday, September 5, 2026

Fate, Destiny, Providence and God’s Plan

In my continuing quest to understand the nature and conflicts of metaphysics and religion, I am intrigued by the question of what we mean when we toss around the terms fate and destiny, and what religious people mean when they speak of providence and of God’s plan.

Both fate and destiny describe some form of predetermined future.  However, dictionaries say that fate implies a blind, unchangeable outcome driven by outside forces (fate comes from the Latin Fatum, which means ‘that which has been spoken’), while destiny suggests a purposeful goal shaped at least in part by personal choices and efforts.

In Greek mythology, the ‘fates’ were three sister goddesses who ‘personify the inescapable destiny and lifespan of every mortal and God’. Clotho, the Spinner, spun the thread of life at birth; Lachesis, the measurer, measured the length of the thread, deciding how long that person lives; and Atropos, the inevitable, cut the thread with her shears, marking the exact moment of death.

We speak of accepting one’s fate, and the term fatalistic implies a passive acceptance of what is often a difficult outcome.  People from every era and every culture have bemoaned the often cruel and arbitrary nature of fate.

Fate implies a lack of free will.  If your fate is predetermined, then in theory what you do cannot affect or change it.  Yet even people that accepted the concept of fate continued to act as if they had free will, probably because it is against human nature to cease acting on one’s behalf.  Perhaps they were willing to accept the somewhat dispiriting notion that everything we do is predictable in advance and simply hope for the best.

In the midst of the enlightenment, when the laws of physics and mathematics were being discovered, it was tempting to imagine that the universe was completely deterministic and that everything could in theory be predicted.  This seemed to lend some credibility to the concepts of fate or destiny.  But as science progressed into the twentieth century, the role that chance, noise, probability and randomness/stochasticity play completely changed our perspective and introduced a new level of uncertainty in both the physical and the human world.   

The concept of a predetermined outcome, or fate, is no longer embraced by most rational people unless they believe in a religious version, which is known as providence or more simply, God’s plan.

The monotheistic religions appear to have a spectrum of beliefs about the nature of free will and predetermination.  Many religions believe in predestination, which is similar to fate in that it posits that the entire path of our lives is known by God.  The issue of free will is debated endlessly, and different groups at different times have come up with ways to reconcile predestination and free will.  But contradictions and logical absurdities abound in these attempts to fit ancient concepts of fate and providence into a world where science, logic and reason predominate.

Some theorize that God is outside of time and history and is able to know and observe everything about our lives without denying us free will.  But many of the same people speak of God’s plan as if one’s life has been planned or is at least in the process of being planned as one lives.  How this can coexist with free will is never completely explained.

Most religious people believe that God intercedes in our lives in enacting his plan, but the question of how a merciful and loving God that is acting on our behalf allows horrible things to happen is only vaguely addressed.  The typical answer is that evil occurs because God is not a puppet master and that he allows us free will and that humankind’s sin causes bad things to happen. 

But this is a woefully inadequate and illogical answer.  If God can and does intercede yet allows evil to occur then that begs the question on what basis God intercedes?  Why cure one cancer and not another?  Why save one life in a plane crash and not the rest? The usual response is that God’s ways are mysterious, a profoundly unsatisfying explanation.

Whether fate or providence, the idea of a predetermined path of life is both pain and solace to many.  If one’s life is burdensome and full of failure, then the idea of fate may bring some measure of comfort, as one can rationalize the misfortune as inevitable and avoid responsibility. Similarly, if a great tragedy occurs, some may find relief in believing that God’s plan will bring some good out of it eventually. 

Accepting the fact that events in our lives or in the world may be purely random is difficult and distressing.  But what remains is indeed true free will.  How we react to events can have impact on our own lives and the lives of others.  We do have agency, however feeble it may seem, and we must do what we can to have positive effect.  It is the most needed characteristic of humanity.